As the GL description says, this one is definitely worth trying. I have tried a number of brands, and this is among the best, assuming a couple of things: this is a foamy, very light, and super slick shaving cream. It's best used with pre-shave oil and a good brush. You'll get a ton of smooth foam with a very, very small amount, so the value is outstanding. In terms of quality, it's between a 4 and 5 out of 5. It is way better than something like the Art of Shaving or Kiehl's, and is probably on par with the Jack Black Supreme Cream or Geo F. Trumper, but not quite as good as Truefitt & Hill. I really like the "Mr. Taylor's" scent as well; it's quite old-school, complex, and masculine, and makes me feel like I'm shaving the way my grandpa intended.